NewWelcome to my brand NEW website!My brand NEW website is here! All your favourite recipes are still here, each one with its video.

Fish Pie

Delicious fish pie made with atlantic cod, fried onions, mashed potatoes and a tasty buttery roux.

4.01 rating
Prep
15 min
Cook
30 min
Makes
1 fish pie
Serves
Family
This recipe is in my cookbook What's for Supper?
FISH PIE

About this recipe

Fish Pie
Fresh or salted cod filets, potatoes, onions is some of the ingredients in our tasty fish pie.

This is a lovely quick recipe and can be served with bread, rolls or steamed veggies.

On Christmas Eve we love serving a fish meal, mostly Fish and Brewis 

But sometimes we like to try different seafood meals on that day because after that we will eat turkey for days and its nice to have something different on Christmas Eve, served with homemade Sweet Molasses Raisin Bread

Atlantic cod, skinless, boneless and part cooked then flaked apart and put in sauce.
Atlantic cod, skinless, boneless and part cooked then flaked apart and put in sauce.

http://BonitasKitchen.com/Cookbook

Bonita's Kitchen Cookbook
This is our link to our second cookbook.
FISH PIE
Delicious fish pie made with atlantic cod, fried onions, mashed potatoes and a tasty buttery roux.

If you are looking for a tasty meal made with your local fish or atlantic cod, we have a lovely FISH PIE recipe here.

You can make with any type of fish thats your favourite, just follow our method and make yours today. Don’t forget to watch our short video and our recipes is posted above for your convenience, also please leave us a message before you go.

Homemade fish pie with potatoes, onion, fresh cod filets and so much more.
Homemade fish pie with potatoes, onion, fresh cod filets and so much more.
Dinner is ready! We are having a tasty helping of fish pie with some homemade white bread.
Dinner is ready! We are having a tasty helping of fish pie with some homemade white bread.

Thank you for stopping by, from our kitchen to yours have a wonderful day.

FISH PIE, made with fresh cod filets and mashed potatoes.
FISH PIE, made with fresh cod filets and mashed potatoes.

The recipeFish Pie

One step at a time in big print, and your screen stays on.

Ingredients Tick them off

Method Tap a step to keep your place

  1. Peel, wash and boil potatoes in a medium saucepan with water, ½ tsp sea salt and ¼ of onion, cook until fork tender. Then drain vegetable water into a bowl to use after, then mash potatoes with 1 tbsp of butter and ¼ cup milk.

  2. Grease a pie pan or pan of choice with butter and cover with ½ of the mashed potatoes.

  3. In another medium saucepan add your salted or fresh cod with water and 1/4 of onion for taste, boil for 5 minutes then remove from heat. “ If you are using salted cod soak for about 2 to 3 hours before cooking, discard water” “ if you are using fresh cod and ½ tsp sea salt for taste” when cod is cooked drain and flake apart.

  4. In a frying pan on medium heat fry chopped onions in butter and oil, with a pinch of sea salt and pepper. Fry until part cooked then add flour, fry for another minute, then add vegetable broth, continue cooking until thickened. ‘this is called a drawn butter”

  1. Add flaked cod over mashed potatoes in the pan, making sure ALL bones are removed before using, then add drawn butter” fried onions and flour thickening” over the flaked cod, then top with the remaining mashed potatoes.

  2. Melt ½ tsp butter and brush over the mashed potatoes before baking it in a 350ºF preheated oven for 30 minutes or until golden brown. “ add cheese over top if you wish”

  3. Remove from heat and serve with fresh bread or rolls, and tea. “ mustard pickles or chow chow” corn relish or veggies.

How did it turn out?

Tap a star to rate it.

Allergens
  • Fish
  • Milk
  • Wheat

From my ingredient list. If you have an allergy, always check the labels on what you buy.

Share on Facebook

Email me this recipe

I'll send Fish Pie to your inbox, so it's there when you need it.

Fish Pie

Keeping your screen on

Step 1

Show the ingredients

    Watch me make it

    Filmed in our kitchen by RM Hussey Productions.Open on YouTube

    Join 96,800 people who watch me cook. I post new videos most weeks.

    Subscribe on YouTube

    Leave me a message

    Did you make it? Does it remind you of someone who used to make it? Tell me about it. Your email is never shown.

    Just your town and province or country. It shows beside your name.

    2 messages

    I answered one of them myself.

    1. Shirley Schuurman

      Purchased a small packet of salmon trimmings & decided to make this. Small springform pan, to suit a mount of fish after skin etc removed. Added the summer savoury to the sauce as could not find direction for that in receipe as given. Baked longer to get some browning. Delicious. Would the herb be good added to the mashed potatoes as well? Used half salmon water & half potato water, & veg bouillon cube.

      1. Bonita

        Hi Shirley: Thank you for sharing your message with us on how you made your fish pie. I love salmon and I’m sure it was amazing in this pie, summer savoury is the same as our regular savoury here in NL I’ve used both. Having the salmon water work wonderful as well, the flavours are there. Stay safe and have a lovely day. 🙂 Bonita

    Get my new recipes by email

    A short note from my kitchen with each new recipe and video. You can stop any time.

    Get my new recipes by email

    When I make something new, I'll send you a short note with the recipe and the video. You can stop any time.

    Find a recipe

    Love the new website? Let me know!

    What do you love about it? Tap as many as you like

    I may show your first name and where you're from on my website, like "Sandra from Carbonear loves Cook mode".